|
So you are brand new
to trading and you want to be a successful trader? You'll turn a
small amount of money to a large amount in a very short time?
Yet you have heard that 80% to 90% of those who trade fail to
become financially profitable. You may even have heard from US
statistics that 10% to 12% of new traders become bankrupt within
the first two years.
But you don't believe
these facts or at least you don't believe they apply to you.
Well, I'll let you in
on a secret - the stats do apply to you. And, that really is a
shame since the road to success is clearly laid out; all you
need to is to follow it.
The first step on the road to success is to understand that long
term trading accomplishment is not:
Dependent on
being to forecast "to the day or minute" turning points.
Being "right"
80% of the time.
Being able to
turn "$10,000.00 to $100,000.00 in six months".
Making
$12,000.00 trading one contract trading only once a day in two
weeks.
Finding a
method that generates signals in markets that are 100% accurate.
Etc, etc, etc. You
see these types of ads in every issue of Technical Analysis of
Stocks and Commodities.
Why does believing
the ads set up most beginners to lose? Trading is a probability
game. No one can predict the future - by predict I mean nominate
a time and/or price that the market will turn, without a shadow
of doubt, each and everytime a prediction is made. Once we say
that certainty is impossible, we are dealing with the realm of
probability.
This means a number
of things:
each trade is
unique and independent of previous trades
profits and
losses are randomly distributed
profits are
not dependent on knowing the outcome of an individual trade.
"Indeed, the extent
to which you think you know, assume you know, or in any way have
to know what is going to happen next, is the same degree to
which you will fail as a trader." Mark Douglas, "Trading in the
Zone"
As a novice you have
to fully appreciate these points.
One of the most
important ramifications is that a number of consecutively
successful trades does not mean you have found the Holy Grail of
trading. Similarly the fact that you have had a number of
consecutively unsuccessful trades does not mean you are a
trading failure.
Another important
ramification is that a belief you "know" what the market will do
will often lead to ignoring market information that the forecast
(prediction) is wrong. This in turns leads to the danger that
you will hang on losing position turning a small loss into a
disastrous loss i.e. a loss that takes you out of the game.
OK so we have some
idea of what long term trading success is NOT, now let's have a
look at what it is.
You have come to the
trading world knowing less than nothing, armed only with dreams
of making it big. Generally you will follow one of several
routes:
- you will subscribe
to newsletters or some sort "trading signal" service: Only
problem is you even though you religiously follow all the
signals, you end up losing your capital; or because your capital
is limited, you take only some signals which usually prove to be
the losers.
or you will attend
one seminar after another looking for "wisdom" but all you
become is more confused - Gann, Elliott, P&L Dot, Market
Profile,
or you turn to the
"masters" and they give conflicting advice:
Jim Rodgers
(co-founder of the Quantum fund with George Soros): I haven't
met a rich technician.
Marty Schwartz (one
of the most successful S&P traders): I always laugh at people
who say, 'I have never met a rich technician'…….I used
fundamentals for nine years and then got rich a technician.
Peter Lynch (famed
Equities fund manager and author): Don't bottom fish.
Paul Tudor Jones (well known futures trader): Everyone says you
get killed trying to pick tops and bottoms and you make all the
money by catching the trends in the middle. Well, for twelve
years I have often been missing the meat in the middle, but I
have caught a lot of bottoms and tops.
But through all the
apparent conflicting advice, one pattern emerges.
The trading method you chose must suit your personality and must
have an edge (i.e. give a positive expectation for return).
Issues you need to
look determine before you compose your plan include such matters
as:
Are you more
suited to a mechanical or subjective approach?
A mechanical
approach means once you have developed the plan, you must take
all signals generated by the system. As a general rule, a
mechanical method will have simple, unambiguous rules. It's
trading history will usually reveal drawdowns of 30% or greater.
The
subjective approach will have rules but there will be a
discretionary element in its execution. In addition in coming to
a decision, there will be a discretion in choosing the
information that it applicable to the moment.
A mechanical approach
is best suited to those that prefer clear, unambiguous and
one-dimensional rules. The subjective approach is preferred by
those who can make decisions from a wide variety of information
sources and identifying those items which are relevant to the
situation.
Are you more
suited to buying new highs in uptrends and new lows in
downtrends (breakout trader) or buying the end of corrections
(dips) in uptrends and rallies in downtrends (responsive
trader)?
Most traders
have a predisposition towards breakout trading or responsive
trading. Being to be able to execute as breakout trader as well
as responsive trader is a skill that needs to be learnt.
Do you
operate best if you when you have the luxury of time on your
hands and are suffer little or no anxiety when you hold
positions overnight or do you prefer to make decisions under
time pressure and are highly stressed in holding positions
overnight?
Do you prefer
using fundamentals in your decision making process or are you
more disposed towards the technical approach?
Once you have
identified the important psychological issues, you can look to
the development of your trading plan.
As a technical
trader, I can advise only the those who have a preference for
the technical approach on the elements required for a plan that
has an edge.
Your plan must first have some way of identifying the trend of
the timeframe you are trading and changes in trend in that time
frame. Identifying the trend or change in trend gives you your
strategy. In an uptrend, you are a buyer, in a downtrend a
seller and in a congestion market, you have a number of options:
you can stand
aside
you can
initiate trades in the direction of the previous trend and
liquidate positions at the opposite extreme of the sideways
market.
The rationale
for this is that in the absence of evidence of a change in
trend, the market will exit the sideways market in the direction
of that in came in. Thus if there was an uptrend before the
congestion market, the market will have an upside breakout if
there has been no change in trend.
You can
initiate buys at the bottom end of congestion and initiate sells
at the top end of congestion.
Once you have your
strategy, you then have to implement it - choose your tactics.
The first tactic is to enter the market - what I call low risk
entry.
Low Risk Entry has three components:
1. A Zone:
If you are a breakout trader, this area where the trend has
probably resumed on a breakout basis i.e. a new high in an
uptrend and new low in a downtrend.
If you are a responsive trader, this is the area that probably
marks the end of a correction.
Examples of zones are Fibonacci and Gann retracements, Dynamic
Gann Levels, Steidlmayer Zones, statistical zones.
2) A Setup:
If you are a breakout trader, this is a chart pattern area that
tells you that the breakout is probably valid.
If you are a responsive trader, this is a chart pattern that
tells you a zone is likely to hold.
Setups are found in many described in a number of books. Some of
the more recent ones:
Hit and Run
Trading by Jeff Cooper
StreetSmarts
by Connors and Raschke
Finbonacci
Ratios and Pattern recognition by Pessavento
Stock
patterns for Day Trading by Barry Rudd
3) An entry technique
and initial stop placement.The entry tells you how to enter the
trade and the initial stop placement tells you where the trade
is wrong and where to exit.
It is worth
meantioning that in setting stops, first identify where the stop
should be and then identify if the stop is within your money
management. I do not recommnend placing pure money stops. It is
the nature of markets to back and fill unless they are thrusting
directionally and as a result, pure money stops tend to get
executed. This is the main reason for the trader's lament:
"They gunned my stop and the market then moved my way!" (grr!!!!!)
I am not saying our technical stops don't get hit only to find
that the market then moves in our direction. But it in my
experience pure money stops are inefficient.
Now once we are in a
trade, our plan must set out the rules for managing the trade -
trade management.
Trade Management is
an essential ingredient of the plan and one that most novices
neglect. Trade management can be separated into initial
management and subsequent management.
Initial management
answers the question: "Should I exit a trade even if my stop is
not hit"?
Subsequent management
sets down the way we will protect our profits.
Too often the novice trader belives he has done all he needs to
once he has completed his plan. Nothing could be further from
the truth.
There are two other
planks for trading success. The first of these is an effective
money maangement plan. Effective money management answers a
series of questions. The answer to the questions is dependent on
our financial ability to take a loss, the trading edge of our
plan, the volatility of the markets we will trade and our
psychologically ability to take the loss.
So what are the
questions?
How much
capital do I need to start trading?
Too many
traders come to the markets undercapitalized. Trading is a
business; it is a well known fact that most small businesses
fail from a lack of capital. The same can be said for trading
failure.
How much of
my capital should I risk in any one trade?
How much
capital should I allocate for all my postions at any one time?
How do I
increase the number of traded contracts as my capital increases?
The books I have
found helpful:
"Winner Take
All" by W Gallacher (chapter on Money Management)
"Bankroll
Control" by M Pascual (chapter on commodity trading)
"The Trading
Game" by Ryan Jones
The final element for
successful trading is cultivating a winning psychological
attitude. This is far the most difficult. There are many
important traits that a trdaer needs to cultivate - the books by
Robert Koppel and Howard Abel set these out. But the two most
critical traits are:
a) Accept the outcome of the Trade.
At its core, winning psychology has as its base the "acceptance
of the outcome of a trade".
By acceptance I mean
the ability of being aware of an emotion without "buying into"
its content; some may call this 'mindfulness'.
e.g.Contrast:
Imagine you have just entered a trade and the very next bar is a
big range bar against your position:
"My God here I go
again! Can't I do anything right! What will my wife say if I
take yet another losing trade!
May be I should move
my stop? No I can't do that - the last time it cost me my bank!
But what about the other day when I got stopped out only to have
go my way? This is just too hard!!!!" etc etc.
With:
Imagine you have just entered a trade and the very next bar is a
big range bar against your position:
"The market is
approaching my stop. I feel uncomfortable with the price action
and I can live with the discomfort".
The first trader may
think he has accepted the outcome but in fact he has failed to
do so at the emotional level; the second trader has accepted the
outcome at all levels.
This idea of
acceptance applies not only to loses but to profits as well. The
trader that "accepts" an outcome realizes that on an individual
trade basis a positive outcome on one trade does not translate
into a future of unlimited profits.
At its core
"acceptance" realizes that trading is based on probabilities, as
such every trade is unique. In other words, the past does not
equal the future.
Ultimately to succeed, we, as traders, need to adopt two
apparently contradictory beliefs:
"That the market is
uncertain and unpredictable and that the market is relatively
certain and predictable".
The resolution of
this apparent conflict is found in the timeframes that we hold
the beliefs.
At the trade by trade
level, we hold the first belief. Because the market can and will
probably do anything, we seek first to protect our capital in
the execution of our trading plan. In other words, we must
always have an exit strategy.
At the level of a "large sample size", we hold the second
belief. To the extent our trading plan has an edge, will be the
extent to which the market will be predictable and certain.
In short we accept
that with trading we are dealing with probabilities and not
certainties.
It is of imperative
importance we hold these beliefs not only at an intellectual
level but also at every level of our being - especially the
emotional level.
As a trading coach I have seen, time and again, lip service
acceptance to the idea of probability; but when it comes to
actually trading, the traders behave as if each and every trade
must be a winner - they have a need for certainty. How else can
we explain the popularity of services advertising 90% hit rates?
If the ads were not drawing an adequate response, they would
disappear.
Probability thinking
leads to a host of other states and beliefs:
1. Because we believe
that we will succeed in the long run and because we know we can
protect ourselves no matter what the market does, we acquire the
state of "self trust" and the state of being "carefree"
2. Focused, confident
and carefree when we are experiencing the inevitable prolonged
drawdown.
3. Because at the
trade by trade level we know that the market is random, we will
not allow euphoria to set in and lead us to reckless trades.
Each trade will only be one in a series of probabilities.
4. We will view
market information not as a source of pleasure/pain but merely
as data providing us with opportunities. This is not to say
trading should not be fun; indeed not only should it be but for
most traders it MUST be.
However the fun comes
from the flawless execution of the rules appropriate to our
stage of evolution and not from trade by trade results.
If we accept the
outcome of the trade, we are on our way to overcoming two blocks
to winning psychology:
Fear and
Euphoria.
The universal
fears are:
The fear of
being abandoned and
The fear of
losing control.
If we reflect for a
moment, we'll see how the fear of being abandoned comes about.
As young children, we
are totally dependent on our parents. Very quickly we come to
realize that if they ever abandon us, we shall be unable to care
for ourselves. Most of us fail to confront this fear as we grow
into adulthood. As a result we automatically deal with it by
attempting to control our environment - the people, conditions
and events that surround us.
This tendency to
control may or may not be appropriate in other areas of life but
as a strategy for trading the markets it is a bust. Most of us
are incapable of influencing the market even for the shortest
moment, let alone control it.
The effect of fear is to drive out knowledge; it leads to
myopia; it immobilizes us and leads to inaction.
The mirror image of
fear is euphoria - the feeling that we can do no wrong. As much
as fear, euphoria will ultimately lead to trading failure. Since
trading is a game of probabilities, we will experience times
when we can do no wrong. But these times will come to an end.
The trader caught in the euphoric trance will not recognize this
and taking one risk too many will eventually get caught in a
heavy loss. If he is lucky, the loss will not be a catastrophic
loss.
Fear and Euphoria can
catch not only newbies but also the most experienced and
successful trader. Witness the demise of (Trader) Vic Sperandeo.
Vic started trading public funds in 1972 and for over 25 years
had a very successful career. His view on trading can best be
summarized by the passage below:
"I'm a market professional....and I am very good at what I
do.... I never gamble more than I can afford to lose.... I think
my unique strength is in my consistency.. I pride myself in my
ability to successfully stay in the game..."
(Trader Vic, Methods of a Wall Street Master page ix)
In 1998 Vic was said
to have gone bankrupt as a result of one trade.
Euphoria or Fear?
It doesn't matter.
Whatever the reason, Vic lost a reputed US$50 million and is now
out of the game.
The best book I have
seen on this area is Mark Douglas' "Trading in the Zone"
The other critical element is what has been named "the adversity
quotient" (AQ). What is the adversity quotient? To quote:
"First, AQ is a new
conceptual frmework for understanding and enhancing all facets
of success….Second, AQ is a measure of how you will repond to to
adversity….Finally, AQ is a set of scientifically-grounded tools
for improving how you respond to adversity". (Adversity Quotient
by Paul Stoltz, PhD)
Trading forces us to
face our deepest fears and to shine a light in those dark
corners we would rather leave dark. AQ gives a set of tools that
makes it easier to persist in the face of the greatest of
difficulties.
Trading is simple but
not easy. It is simple because the roadmap to potential success
is clearly laid out; it is not easy because following the map is
difficult.
One thing is clear, there is no short cut - you cannot buy
success (i.e. money alone will not be enough); you can acquire
information but in the last resort, your success is function of
the effort (time, energy and money) you put in.
Ray Barros
The articles presented on this website are solely
for informational purposes. No offer or solicitation to buy or
sell currencies, or any type of investment or trading advice or
strategy, is made, given or in any manner endorsed by
LearnTrading or its affiliates. You are fully responsible for
any investment or trading decisions you make, and such decisions
should be based solely on your evaluation of your financial
circumstances, investment or trading objectives, risk tolerance
and liquidity needs.
No warranties are given by LearnTrading and no warranties are
implied regarding the content of the article(s) which can be
accessed through this website. LearnTrading shall not be liable
in any way for losses or liability of any kind to any person
resulting directly or indirectly through the use in any way by
such person of the information referred to and/or use of the
suggested reading material or the website(s), however such loss
or liability occurs, and whether financial or otherwise. The
pages and the opinions or information contained in the suggested
reading material or these website(s) are the creation of outside
parties and do not necessarily reflect the opinions or
representations of LearnTrading.
|